| Título: | Comparison of feedback generated by experts and learners during formative evaluation |
| Autores: | Israeloff, Alanna |
| Fecha: | 1992 |
| Publicador: | McGill University - MCGILL |
| Fuente: |
 |
| Tipo: | Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
| Tema: |
Learning, Psychology of Specialists. |
| Descripción: | Despite the recommendation to use both expert and learner feedback during formative evaluation, little research has compared the differences in data produced by these two sources. The presents study examines the differences in feedback produced by experts and learners. Six sessions with experts and six sessions with learners were conducted to obtain feedback about a six page instructional unit. The think-aloud method was used to gather data from experts and the talk-aloud method was used with learners. Comments from experts and learners were transcribed, segmented, and coded according to two coding system which addressed both the amount and type of feedback. Results indicated that when compared to learners, experts identify a higher percentage of problems, make more comments related to their knowledge of the subject matter, provide more revision suggestions, and summarize their comments and actions more often. Learners elaborate more about each problem and focus on issues related to instructional design and language. The findings support the use of both experts and learners to evaluate instruction. |
| Idioma: | en |
1 Investigations on the form-genera Beauveria and Tritirachium por MacLeod, Donald Murdock | 6 Treatment and recovery in first-episode psychosis : a qualitative analysis of client experiences por Windell, Deborah L. |
2 Seismic sensitivity of tall guyed telecommunication towers. por Ghodrati Amiri, Gholamreza. | 7 |
3 Exploring the Relationship Between Assets and Family Stress Among Low-Income Families por Rothwell, David W.,Han, Chang-Keun | 8 |
4 The case for asset-based interventions with indigenous peoples: Evidence from Hawai‘i por Rothwell, David W. | 9 |
5 Second Thoughts: Who Almost Participates in an IDA Program? por Rothwell, David W.,Han, Chang-Keun | 10 Recent contributions to the phenomenology of musical time : a critical survey por Beaudreau, Pierre |