| Título: | Comparison of feedback generated by subject matter and learner experts during formative evaluation |
| Autores: | Tremblay, Diana |
| Fecha: | 1994 |
| Publicador: | McGill University - MCGILL |
| Fuente: |
 |
| Tipo: | Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
| Tema: | Teaching -- Aids and devices -- Evaluation |
| Descripción: | The literature on formative evaluation advocates the use of both subject matter and learner experts to review instructional materials, yet there has been little research to support this recommendation. The present study investigates the distinguishing characteristics of these two expert reviewers, in particular the type and amount of oral feedback they produced and the cognitive processes they engaged in. The think-aloud method was employed to obtain feedback about a six page instructional unit from eight experts; four subject matter and four learner experts. Comments from the experts were transcribed, segmented and coded according to three coding systems. Results indicated that the two groups produced similar data. In addition, the findings showed that both groups referred to similar domains of knowledge, evoked or constructed similar plans and identified their task as detecting problems. These findings contradict the use of both types of experts during formative evaluation. Some practical recommendations for practitioners are offered. |
| Idioma: | en |
1 Investigations on the form-genera Beauveria and Tritirachium por MacLeod, Donald Murdock | 6 Treatment and recovery in first-episode psychosis : a qualitative analysis of client experiences por Windell, Deborah L. |
2 Seismic sensitivity of tall guyed telecommunication towers. por Ghodrati Amiri, Gholamreza. | 7 |
3 Exploring the Relationship Between Assets and Family Stress Among Low-Income Families por Rothwell, David W.,Han, Chang-Keun | 8 |
4 The case for asset-based interventions with indigenous peoples: Evidence from Hawai‘i por Rothwell, David W. | 9 |
5 Second Thoughts: Who Almost Participates in an IDA Program? por Rothwell, David W.,Han, Chang-Keun | 10 Recent contributions to the phenomenology of musical time : a critical survey por Beaudreau, Pierre |