| Título: | Conditional Hospitality: Framing Dialogue on Poverty in Montréal Newspapers |
| Autores: | Nielsen, Greg M.; Sociology and Anthropology, Concordia University |
| Fecha: | 2008-12-31 |
| Publicador: | Canadian Journal of Comumunication |
| Fuente: |
 |
| Tipo: |
info:eu-repo/semantics/article research-article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion |
| Tema: |
Cultural analysis; Jourrnalism; Televison; Communication Poverty; Conditional hospitality; Journalism; Implied audience; Dialogic frames; Montréal |
| Descripción: | Abstract: A paradox of the mainstream press is that while the poor are represented regularly in supportive but conditional tones of hospitality in newspaper reports, journalists rarely address the poor as their imagined or implied audience. Not engaging the poor as an audience in a civic dialogue means that our understanding of poverty is diminished and remains conditional even when the press pleads for greater hospitality or refuge. Following Jacques Derrida, Mikhail Bakhtin and Robert Entman, I develop a dialogic framing analysis of the relations between journalists, their implied audiences, and the poor as subjects of the reports. Analysis of three online mainstream newspapers in Montréal illustrates how the conditional discourse of hospitality is established through particular forms of address.Résumé : C’est un paradoxe de la presse dominante que les reportages représentent les pauvres avec compassion à certaines conditions mais s’adressent rarement à eux comme faisant partie intégrante de leur public imaginé ou implicite. Les journaux, en négligeant d’inclure les pauvres dans le dialogue civique qu’ils entretiennent avec leurs publics cibles, diminuent notre compréhension de la pauvreté, même quand ils plaident pour une meilleure hospitalité ou un meilleur accueil à l’égard des pauvres. En m’inspirant de Jacques Derrida, Mikhail Bakhtin et Robert Entman, je développe dans cet article une analyse dialogique de l’encadrement des rapports entre les journalistes, leurs publics implicites et les pauvres en tant qu’objets de reportages. L’analyse de trois grands journaux montréalais en ligne illustre comment un discours de l’hospitalité conditionnelle se réalise à travers des formes d’adresse particulières. |
| Idioma: | Inglés |
1 Metro Toronto Media: A Combustible Situation por Beattie, Earle; Editor | 6 K.C. Irving Case por Beattie, Earle |
2 The Ontario Press Council por Lunn, Richard | 7 Mercy Killing of the Star Weekly: The F.P.-Southam-Star Syndrome por Beattie, Earle |
3 Can the CBC Be Spotless? por Rogers, Bruce | 8 What Are the Questions, Questions? por Beattie, Earle |
4 Must We Be Ambushed by the Future? por Zwicker, Barrie | 9 What Media Probe Is All About por Beattie, Earle |
5 Public Ax-cess to the Newspaper por Beattie, Earle | 10 University of Toronto Library Science as Communication por Beattie, Earle |