| Título: | Birding 2.0: Citizen Science and Effective Monitoring in the Web 2.0 World |
| Autores: | Wiersma, Yolanda F.; Department of Biology, Memorial University; ywiersma@mun.ca |
| Fecha: | 2010-12-31 |
| Publicador: | Avian Consevation & Ecology |
| Fuente: | |
| Tipo: |
Peer-Reviewed Essay |
| Tema: |
citizen science; citizen sensors; experimental design; monitoring; volunteered geographical information (VGI); Web 2.0 |
| Descripción: | The amateur birding community has a long and proud tradition of contributing to bird surveys and bird atlases. Coordinated activities such as Breeding Bird Atlases and the Christmas Bird Count are examples of "citizen science" projects. With the advent of technology, Web 2.0 sites such as eBird have been developed to facilitate online sharing of data and thus increase the potential for real-time monitoring. However, as recently articulated in an editorial in this journal and elsewhere, monitoring is best served when based on a priori hypotheses. Harnessing citizen scientists to collect data following a hypothetico-deductive approach carries challenges. Moreover, the use of citizen science in scientific and monitoring studies has raised issues of data accuracy and quality. These issues are compounded when data collection moves into the Web 2.0 world. An examination of the literature from social geography on the concept of "citizen sensors" and volunteered geographic information (VGI) yields thoughtful reflections on the challenges of data quality/data accuracy when applying information from citizen sensors to research and management questions. VGI has been harnessed in a number of contexts, including for environmental and ecological monitoring activities. Here, I argue that conceptualizing a monitoring project as an experiment following the scientific method can further contribute to the use of VGI. I show how principles of experimental design can be applied to monitoring projects to better control for data quality of VGI. This includes suggestions for how citizen sensors can be harnessed to address issues of experimental controls and how to design monitoring projects to increase randomization and replication of sampled data, hence increasing scientific reliability and statistical power. |
| Idioma: | Inglés |
1 Basic Science, Applied Science, and the Radical Middle Ground por Nudds, Thomas D; University of Guelph; tnudds@uoguelph.ca,Villard, Marc-André; Université de Moncton; villarm@UMoncton.CA | 6 Endangered Species, Provincialism, and a Continental Approach to Bird Conservation por Craig, Robert J; Bird Conservation Research, Inc.; mail@birdconservationresearch.org |
2 Mobile Incubation in Waved Albatross (Phoebastria irrorata): Associated Hatching Failure and Artificial Mitigation por Awkerman, Jill A; Wake Forest University; awkeja2@wfu.edu,Huyvaert, Kathryn P; Colorado State University; huyvaert@cnr.colostate.edu,Anderson, David J; Wake Forest University; da@wfu.edu | 7 Rediscovering the King of Woodpeckers: Exploring the Implications por Walters, Jeffrey R; Virginia Tech; jrwalt@vt.edu,Crist, Eileen L.; Virginia Tech; ecrist@vt.edu |
3 Stable Isotope Analysis Reveals That Agricultural Habitat Provides an Important Dietary Component for Nonbreeding Dunlin por Evans Ogden, Lesley Joan; University of British Columbia; lesleyje@interchange.ubc.ca,Hobson, Keith A; Canadian Wildlife Service; Keith.Hobson@EC.GC.CA,Lank, David B; Simon Fraser University; dlank@sfu.ca,Bittman, Shabtai; Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada; bittmans@agr.gc.ca | 8 Upland Nesting Prairie Shorebirds: Use of Managed Wetland Basins and Accuracy of Breeding Surveys por Gratto-Trevor, Cheri L.; Canadian Wildlife Service; cheri.gratto-trevor@ec.gc.ca |
4 Sea Surface Temperatures Mediated by the El Niño-Southern Oscillation Affect Birds Breeding in Temperate Coastal Rain Forests por Gaston, Anthony J; Canadian Wildlife Service; tony.gaston@ec.gc.ca,Martin, Jean-Louis; Centre National de Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier; ,Allombert, Sylvain; Centre National de Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier; | 9 Spatial Aggregation of Forest Songbird Territories and Possible Implications for Area Sensitivity por Bourque, Julie; ; julie.bourque@ec.gc.ca,Desrochers, André; Université Laval; andre.desrochers@sbf.ulaval.ca |
5 Scale and Sensitivity of Songbird Occurrence to Landscape Structure in a Harvested Boreal Forest por Taylor, Philip D; Acadia University; philip.taylor@acadiau.ca,Krawchuk, Meg A; University of Alberta; megk@ualberta.ca | 10 Identification of Summer Origins of Songbirds Migrating through Southern Canada in Autumn por Dunn, Erica H.; Environment Canada; Erica.Dunn@ec.gc.ca,Hobson, Keith A.; Environment Canada; Keith.Hobson@ec.gc.ca,Wassenaar, Len I.; Environment Canada; Len.Wassenaar@ec.gc.ca,Hussell, David J. T.; Ontario Ministry of Natural Resources; David.Hussell@mnr.gov.on.ca,Allen, Martha L.; Trent University; martha.allen@sympatico.ca |